X-Men: The Last Stand

Rating: 3 out of 5
Directed by Brett Ratner
Starring: Hugh Jackman
[Logan/Wolverine], Halle Berry [Ororo Munroe/Storm], Ian McKellen [Eric
Lensherr/Magneto], Famke Janssen [Jean Grey/Phoenix], Anna Paquin
[Marie/Rogue], Kelsey Grammer [Dr. Hank McCoy/Beast], Rebecca Romijn
[Raven Darkholme/Mystique], James Marsden [Scott Summers/Cyclops],
Shawn Ashmore [Bobby Drake/Iceman], Vinnie Jones [Cain
Marko/Juggernaut], Aaron Stanford [John Allerdyce/Pyro], Patrick
Stewart [Professor Charles Xavier], Ben Foster [Warren Worthington
III/Angel], Dania Ramirez [Callisto], Olivia Williams [Dr. Moira
MacTaggart], Daniel Cudmore [Piotr Rasputin/Colossus], Ellen Page
[Kitty Pryde/Shadowcat], Michael Murphy [Warren Worthington, Sr.],
Shohreh Aghdashloo [Dr. Kavita Rao], Cameron Bright [Jimmy/Leech], Bill
Duke [Bolivar Trask]
Viewed on the big screen
IF YOU HAVEN’T SEEN THE FILM YET, BE WARNED. THIS REVIEW HAS SOME SPOILERS. READ AT YOUR OWN RISK.
As I start writing this, I’m still unsure about how I feel about X-Men: The Last Stand.
It’s a good thing I sat through it twice today. Was is a great movie?
Was it exactly what I, and many fan boys like me, expected? Is Brett Ratner (really) a hack or a genius? Is this really the mutants’ last stand?
I
guess anticipation, speculation and a very vivid and creative
imagination made this movie "bigger" than it seemed in my mind even
before I saw it. "Hyped up" is the right term (my fault entirely).
After all the first two movies did very well in introducing the mutants
and their struggles (in 2000’s X-Men) and it carried on telling another story of their conflicts with mankind and fellow mutants (in 2003’s X2: X-Men United). So you see why I had such a great level of expectation for this film… to do well.
But
how do I determine if it did well? Would it be in terms of awesome
action? Good storytelling? Pacing? Special effects? Or do I have to
look at X3 in a trilogy context to fully appreciate it? (Where the heck
is this review going?)
I went to the theater early today with
about 10 months worth of pent up excitement and with only a few hours
of sleep. I was nervous waiting for the 20th Century Fox fanfare to come on. I was ecstatic to see that the Marvel logo featured all X-Men comic book pages this time.
The film starts with a flashback to 20 years where we see a pre-wheel chair Charles Xavier (Patrick Stewart) and a pre-Magneto Erik Lensherr (Ian McKellen) visiting a young Jean Grey (Haley Ramm)
to invite her to Xavier’s School for the Gifted. It is established in
this scene how much power Jean has and how protectively Xavier oversees
mutants and their use of powers.
This is followed by a 10 year flashback to a young Warren Worthington III (Cayden Boyd) attempting to amputate his (presumably) newly-sprouted wings from his back. A very emotional moment.
These
two scenes serve as the film’s prologue. There was no monologue from
Professor X at this point and that for me somehow made the film
inconsistent with the other two movies as the monologue was practically
a trademark of the X-films. Well, at least the door to Cerebro was
present.
After the opening credits, the movie wastes no time. It
gets right down to business and moves at a frenetic pace, switching
from action scenes to character moments without seemingly stopping to
catch a breath. And it’s this aspect of the film that somehow didn’t
quite work for me. Yes, the plot is tension filled and is already an
escalation from the previous two, but some scenes just didn’t linger
long enough for the audience to deeply root their emotions on. In terms
of storytelling, the film doesn’t slow down in areas where it should
have.
In terms of action, X3 is loaded with it. More mutants are
featured here and more of them display their powers. This movie is
bursting at the seams with action, most of which are well placed and
appropriately used (like the "hide-and-seek" scene between Kitty Pryde [Ellen Page] and the Juggernaut [Vinnie Jones]).
The final Phoenix scene, however, left me wondering what it was for and
I felt it was misplaced and almost useless. But other than that, the
action in this film is superb. The special effects were also good and
some were even amazing. The 20-year flashback scene was astonishing as
it made Stewart and McKellen look apparently younger than they are.
In the acting department, the original cast members and the new ones did their jobs well. Halle Berry’s Storm and Hugh Jackman’s Wolverine are the most prominent characters in X3. Famke Janssen
has a very promising part in the conflicted Jean Grey/Phoenix role. In
fact, I think she did very well with what little was given to her.
Sadly her character wasn’t given enough depth and enough lines to say.
A wasted opportunity.
Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen are as good as ever. Their characters have some pretty interesting developments in this film. Aaron Stanford’s
portrayal of Pyro is a stand out. He’s only in the very few scenes but
he owns each appearance he makes. All the other actors, even the ones
with smaller roles (like Cameron Bright, who played Leech), gave good performances.
The
script had a lot of potential as it was indeed superior to the first
two X-Men films, in my opinion. The problem was with how the story was
written and with how it was interpreted on-screen. The idea of a cure
for mutancy is actually quite a brilliant plot device as it practically
represents a lot of different things to different people. And of
course, the Dark Phoenix saga in itself would have made the script
complex. Simon Kinberg and Zak Penn did a good job, I
think, but they could have done better. I don’t know if their words got
lost in translation (from paper to film) or if the finished product is
what it is because of Ratner, but The Last Stand lacks something I
can’t put my finger on yet.
I did enjoy John Powell’s
score for the film and I think he took the X-Men soundtrack to the next
level. The main title theme really evoked a sense of action, urgency
and excitement that these films have been known for. It is definitely
as good as John Ottman’s X2 theme. Powell’s music for the dramatic scenes also hit home.
There
are still a lot of things I want to tackle about this film. I’d like to
pick it apart and discuss it thoroughly with anyone interested in
comparing notes (especially on the deaths of significant characters and
the ending that pretty much leaves room for another sequel, which is
good!). But let me just end this review by saying that as a stand alone
film, X-Men: The Last Stand is good, action-packed, fast-paced and not
totally deficient in drama. It could have been better, though. As part
of the X-Men trilogy, it’s an almost coherent final installment with
some similarities and references to the two previous films, as there
were some things that for me wasn’t quite explained and rounded up.
If
you’re an X-Men fan like me, you’d really love the stunts, the use of
powers, the running around, the jumping, the walking-through-walls, the
weather-controlling, the full on mutant war. If you’re an X-Men fan and
a detail freak, you will find certain things here that won’t quite
relate harmoniously to the first two installments. If you’re an X-Men
fan, a detail freak and have a voraciously imaginative mind, this movie
will fall short of your expectations — I guess that’s what happened to
me. The X3 version in my mind was actually far better than Brett
Ratner’s. Oh well.
But I enjoyed the movie. It is good and has
so far been one of the very exciting films this summer. So, go ahead
and watch it if you haven’t yet. Just be sure to sit through the very
end of the end credits because I know it’ll make your day better!









